Best Car Warranty Reviews

Reviewed Companies

Best Car Warranty Reviews

Comprehensive reviews from third parties and actual customers to help you find the best car warranty based on reviews. The opinions expressed within the content are solely the author’s and do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of the website or our affiliates. Vehicle Service Contracts are also known as auto warranty, extended auto warranty, aftermarket car warranty, etc. Vehicle names, logos, brands, & other trademarks featured or referred to within Warranty Reviews are property of their respective trademark holders.

Rapid Auto Protection Logo

Rapid Auto Protection


According to Rapid Auto Protection, they offer the same extended vehicle service contracts (extended warranties) car dealers trust now available direct to consumers. Their best coverage is called Exclusionary Coverage. Exclusionary Coverage is often referred to a bumper-to-bumper warranty. The exclusionary coverage is as close to your manufactory warranty you can get. Rapid Auto Protection is new to the direct-to-consumer extended warranty business. However, their vehicle coverage options have been offered by dealerships all over the country for over 20 years. We spoke to a few dealerships about their interactions with the company. Every company said they were easy to work with, pay quickly, and were a very reputable company.


  • Exclusionary coverage
  • Dealers have been offering their extended warranty for decades
  • Offers vehicle, RV, Trailer, Powersports, Motorcycle, & Home Warranties


  • New to the direct-to-consumer space
Endurance Auto Warranty

Endurance Warranty Services, L.L.C.

  • 3.6 / 5
  • 4 / 5
  • 4.3 / 5

Based on 20,766 ratings


BBB Rating & Accreditation: D - This business is not BBB accredited. Years in business: 17. BBB files indicate that this business has a pattern of complaints. Consumers allege that their claims are being denied for various reasons, Mile discrepancy between what the consumer told EWS vs Carfax, Repair not covered under contract even though the contract states that it is covered, Company claims issues were “pre-existing conditions”, Consumers allege long delays with inspection in order to authorize repairs, Consumers allege that they have difficulty cancelling their plan/contract, Poor customer service overall due to lack of communication or unable to reach anyone at the company.

Carshield Logo


  • 4.5 / 5
  • 4.1 / 5
  • 1 / 5

Based on 9350 44881 287 ratings


BBB Rating & Accreditation: C- - This business is not BBB accredited. Years in business: 19. BBB advises consumers to use caution if considering doing business with CarShield. Employed misleading sales and advertising practices, including TV advertisements stating consumers will not be responsible for expensive repairs and can take their vehicle to any repair facility which consumers found was not to be true. Failed to cover repairs. Failed to adequately explain mileage and time component before coverage begins. Did not cancel their policies and provide refunds. Delayed taking and processing claims leaving customers without their vehicles. Unable to find an authorized repair shop. Provided poor customer service.

Olive Logo


  • 4.4 / 5

Based on 557 ratings


BBB Rating & Accreditation: A+ - BBB accredited since 2020. Years in business: 23. Mechanical breakdown coverage provider.

Carchex Logo


  • 4.3 / 5
  • 2.3 / 5
  • 3.9 / 5

Based on 5886 ratings


BBB Rating & Accreditation: A+ - BBB accredited since 2009. Years in business: 24. This organization is a 2011 finalist and 2012 award recipient of BBB Greater Maryland's Torch Awards for Marketplace Excellence.

Protect My Car Logo

Protect My Car

  • 3.7 / 5
  • 4.1 / 5
  • 4 / 5

Based on 7,725 ratings


BBB Rating & Accreditation: C - This business is not BBB accredited Years in business: 18

Best Car Warranty Reviews

Top Picks: The Best Car Warranty Reviews and Comparisons (2024)

Looking for a car warranty that offers the best protection and value? In this article, we demystify the options and lay out the top car warranty providers based on our detailed “best car warranty reviews”. From coverage and costs to customer satisfaction, find out which warranties stand out in the 2024 market. This is your straightforward guide to informed choices in car warranties, steering clear of sales jargon and bias.

Best Car Warranty Reviews (summary)

An extensive review of top car warranty providers in 2024 highlights Endurance for comprehensive coverage, Olive for a seamless online experience, CarShield for affordability, CARCHEX for used and high-mileage vehicles, and Protect My Car for flexible payment and maintenance benefits.

New to the direct-to-consumer warranty model, Rapid Auto Protection offers the the most comprehensive type of extended warranty you can purchase for a vehicle. This coverage is often referred to “bumper-to-bumper” coverage.

When choosing an extended car warranty, it’s crucial to consider factors such as coverage levels, deductibles, budget considerations, and preferred repair shops. The advantages of automaker warranties should be weighed against the flexibility and affordability of third-party providers.

Extended car warranty costs vary based on the vehicle’s age, make, model, and mileage. It is important to understand the pricing structure, compare personalized quotes from top providers, and recognize the value of customer service reputation and convenience when selecting a warranty plan.

Top 5 Car Warranty Providers: In-Depth Reviews

Choosing the best car warranty provider is crucial for any car owner who values peace of mind on the road. After meticulous research based on cost, coverage options, industry reputation, and customer experience, we’ve identified the top car warranty companies in the 2024 market. Let’s take a closer look at each provider to understand their strengths and how they can cater to your vehicle protection needs.

Rapid Auto Protection (BONUS)

Rapid Auto Protection offers multiple plans including Powertrain, Powertrain Plus, Comprehensive (similar to other companies warranty coverage), and Exclusionary Coverage. The coverage Rapid Auto Warranty offers is offered by many dealer extended warranties and is new to the direct-to-consumer space. 

Rapid’s Exclusionary Coverage

Exclusionary car coverage, often known as “bumper-to-bumper” warranty or coverage, represents the most all-encompassing extended warranty option available for vehicles. In contrast to stated component coverage, which only protects specific parts outlined in the warranty agreement, exclusionary coverage seeks to protect nearly every mechanical and electrical part of the car, from the front to the rear bumper.

This type of coverage closely mirrors the original factory warranty provided with new cars, offering a level of reassurance akin to that of owning a new vehicle. It is especially beneficial for owners of used or luxury vehicles, where repair costs can be steep. However, it’s crucial to carefully review the details to grasp precisely what is and isn’t included.

How Exclusionary Coverage Functions

The term “exclusionary” describes the method of defining the coverage; rather than enumerating all the covered components, the warranty specifies the parts that are not covered, or “excluded.” As a result, exclusionary policies provide the widest scope of protection, covering almost all vehicle parts and systems with only a few exceptions.

Endurance: Comprehensive Coverage and Customer Service

Endurance stands out as an extended warranty company among extended car warranty companies with its comprehensive coverage and exceptional customer service. As one of the top extended warranty companies, Endurance has become a leading direct extended warranty provider in the car warranty sector, offering peace of mind to vehicle owners across the country. Their wide range of plan options and a high overall score of 4.6 from the editorial team ensure that every car owner can find the perfect fit for their needs.

Customers have the flexibility to choose any ASE Certified mechanic, shop, or dealership for repairs, highlighting Endurance’s commitment to convenience. Moreover, the extensive coverage provided by Endurance allows customers to choose from a vast network of service providers, ensuring that no matter where you are, your car is protected. This flexibility is complemented by a strong customer service reputation, which is evident from the positive feedback and high ratings by customers and industry experts alike.

Olive: Seamless Online Experience and Customization

Olive is revolutionizing the extended car warranty space with its seamless online experience and a high degree of customization. Customers praise Olive’s representatives for their patience, knowledge, and ability to resolve issues efficiently. The ease of obtaining coverage online, sometimes within minutes, demonstrates Olive’s commitment to a hassle-free customer experience.

This provider has carved a niche in California, where it’s recognized for providing service in a market where some customers struggle to find coverage. Olive’s car warranty solutions are not only affordable but also comprehensive, offering a blanket of security that vehicle owners greatly appreciate. Additionally, customers have shared positive experiences regarding Olive’s efficient repair processes, which are facilitated by the coverage’s breadth.

The no-pressure approach Olive takes with its coverage advocates is a breath of fresh air in an industry often associated with high-pressure sales tactics. One customer testimonial highlights the straightforward communication and direct answers to insurance coverage questions, emphasizing the value that Olive places on transparency and customer satisfaction.

CarShield: Affordable Monthly Payments and Specialty Plans

CarShield offers:

  • Affordability and specialty plans
  • Catering to a wide range of vehicles and budgets
  • Recognition for Best Monthly Payments in 2024 from some review companies
  • Some of the most competitive pricing in the industry

Their monthly payment plans, ranging from $89 to $130, make extended car warranties accessible to a broader audience, while keeping extended car warranty costs in mind.

CARCHEX: Ideal for Used Cars and High Mileage Vehicles

When it comes to protecting used cars and high-mileage vehicles, CARCHEX emerges as a top choice. Offering extended warranties for vehicles with up to 250,000 miles, CARCHEX provides peace of mind for those who drive their cars for the long haul. Their specialized coverage plans make them a suitable choice for used car owners who require protection tailored to their vehicle’s specific needs.

Protect My Car: Flexible Payment Terms and Maintenance Benefits

Protect My Car distinguishes itself with flexible payment terms and valuable maintenance benefits. The average monthly cost for their Supreme plan falls between $100 and $130, demonstrating their commitment to affordability over a four-year period. With the cost to activate a warranty plan ranging between $50 and $100, Protect My Car ensures that comprehensive warranty coverage remains within reach for a wide range of car owners.

Choosing the Right Extended Car Warranty

Selecting the right extended car warranty requires careful consideration of several factors. Whether obtained directly from automakers, dealerships, or third-party warranty companies, extended warranties can vastly differ in terms of coverage, cost, and convenience. Let’s delve into the aspects you should weigh before making a decision.

Factors to Consider

When shopping for an extended car warranty, it’s essential to consider the following:

  • The variety of coverage levels available, including the length of the warranty term
  • The deductible in the service contract, which will impact your out-of-pocket costs
  • Finding a balance that works for your budget
  • Ensuring that your preferred repair shop is approved by the warranty provider for service utilization.

Pros and Cons of Automaker vs. Third-Party Providers

The choice between an automaker’s extended warranty and a third-party provider’s extended auto warranty can significantly affect your extended warranty coverage experience. Automaker warranties typically offer the advantage of using genuine parts for repairs and factory-trained technicians for service.

On the other hand, third-party providers of vehicle service contracts tend to offer more flexible and affordable options, with a broader range of coverage benefits suited to different vehicles and driving needs.

Cost Analysis: Extended Car Warranty Pricing

The cost of an extended car warranty is a crucial factor for many car owners. Prices can vary significantly based on several influencing factors, including:

  • The vehicle’s age
  • Make
  • Model
  • Mileage

Let’s break down the pricing structure and provide guidance on how to compare quotes effectively.

Average Extended Warranty Costs

Average extended warranty costs can vary widely, with factors such as the level of coverage and deductible playing a significant role. For instance, providers like Endurance offer plans with monthly costs ranging from $69 to $180 and down payments between $150 to $350. When considering these costs, it’s important to factor in the length of coverage and the specific terms to ensure you’re getting a plan that meets your needs and budget.

Comparing Quotes from Top Providers

To ensure you’re getting the best value for your money, it’s vital to compare personalized quotes from various companies. This allows you to assess the full range of options available for your specific vehicle and driving habits. Keep in mind that the total cost for warranty plans can exhibit a wide price range, with factors like coverage term lengths greatly influencing the final quote.

Tips for Identifying Trustworthy Warranty Providers

Identifying a trustworthy extended car warranty provider is key to ensuring that your coverage will stand the test of time and unforeseen repairs. There are several indicators to look out for, including company history, business practices, and customer feedback.

Let’s explore how to separate the dependable providers from the rest.

Recognizing Red Flags

High-pressure sales tactics, negative customer reviews, and frequent complaints about claims denials are all red flags that can signal an unreliable warranty provider. A warranty company with a long-standing history is generally more dependable, as it’s more likely to honor claims in the future.

It’s also important to pay attention to a provider’s BBB ratings, as these can be indicative of the company’s reliability.

Utilizing Online Reviews and Industry Resources

Online platforms like Trustpilot, Google, and the Better Business Bureau are excellent resources for customer reviews and can give you insight into a company’s reputation. Additionally, industry resources such as Consumer Affairs and Consumers Advocate can provide comprehensive reviews and feedback on a company’s performance.

A high BBB rating signifies that a company is responsive and effective in resolving issues, which is an important factor when considering their reputation.

Understanding Extended Car Warranty Terms and Coverage

Extended car warranties cover a range of repairs but come with various terms, conditions, and exclusions. Understanding the fine print of your warranty agreement is crucial to ensuring that you’re fully aware of what’s covered and what’s not. Let’s dive into the different types of coverage and what you need to know about exclusions and limitations.

Types of Coverage: Bumper-to-Bumper vs. Powertrain

The level of coverage you choose, be it a bumper to bumper warranty or powertrain, will determine the extent to which your vehicle is protected. Bumper-to-bumper coverage is the most comprehensive, covering most vehicle systems excluding normal wear and tear.

Powertrain warranties, on the other hand, focus on the essential components of your vehicle, such as the engine and transmission.

Exclusions and Limitations

It’s critical to be aware of the exclusions and limitations in your extended car warranty. For example:

  • ‘Bumper-to-bumper’ does not necessarily mean everything between the bumpers is covered.
  • Wear and tear items like tires and batteries are usually not included.
  • There may be specific exclusions for certain powertrain components.

Understanding these details will help you navigate your warranty effectively and avoid surprises when it comes time for repairs.

Making the Most of Your Extended Car Warranty

To truly benefit from your extended car warranty, you need to:

  1. Be well-versed in its terms and conditions
  2. Understand the network of approved repair facilities
  3. Know how to work with these resources
  4. Make the most of the additional perks

By doing so, you can significantly enhance the value of your warranty.

Let’s explore how to maximize these benefits for the best coverage experience.

Working with Approved Repair Facilities

A smooth claims process is contingent on working with repair facilities approved by your warranty administrator. By ensuring that the administrator handles the claim, you can avoid potential issues and ensure that your repairs are covered.

It also means that payments to repair facilities are managed effectively, making the process hassle-free for you.

Roadside Assistance and Rental Car Reimbursement

Many extended car warranties offer additional benefits, such as roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement, which can be invaluable in the event of a breakdown. These perks ensure that you’re not left stranded and can continue with your day with minimal disruption.

Understanding how to access and use these benefits is key to making the most of your extended car warranty.


In summary, an extended car warranty is an investment in your vehicle’s longevity and your peace of mind. By thoroughly researching providers, understanding the terms and coverage options, and making informed decisions based on cost and reputation, you can select a warranty that best suits your needs. Remember, the right extended car warranty can turn a potential roadside headache into a minor inconvenience, allowing you to enjoy the journey with confidence.